Personalized online counselling based on cognitive behavioral principles does not significantly improve sleep efficiency in shift workers compared to sleep diary completion alone.
In a randomized controlled trial of 66 German shift workers, both the intervention group receiving four personalized counselling messages and weekly sleep diaries and the control group completing only sleep diaries showed significant improvements in sleep efficiency, insomnia symptoms, and depression symptoms over four weeks. However, the improvements were not significantly greater in the intervention group than in the control group, failing to demonstrate superiority of the counselling intervention. Daytime sleepiness did not improve in either group.
This article is automatically generated from the structured evidence profile behind the claim above. Scores reflect the quality and quantity of available research, not clinical advice.
Personalized online counselling based on cognitive behavioral principles does not significantly improve sleep efficiency in shift workers compared to sleep diary completion alone. The current body of evidence comprises 1 study, including 1 randomized controlled trial. EvidenceHub rates the overall confidence at 48/100 (low).
The Claim
Personalized online counselling based on cognitive behavioral principles does not significantly improve sleep efficiency in shift workers compared to sleep diary completion alone.
This conclusion is most relevant to: German shift workers from various industries with sleep complaints.
What the Research Shows
The conclusion draws on 1 linked study. Highlights from the cited literature:
- ▸Efficacy of an anonymous, preventive, personalized online counselling to improve shift workers' sleep quality: a randomized controlled trial. (Scientific reports, 2026) —
How It Works
The proposed biological pathway:
- ▸Participants received personalized counselling messages adapted to shift work
- ▸Participants completed weekly sleep diaries
- ▸Control group completed sleep diaries only
- ▸Both groups showed improvements, but no significant difference between groups
Who Might Benefit
Evidence fit by population:
- ▸German shift workers from various industries with sleep complaints
Recommended Dose
N/A
Limitations & Caveats
Important context when interpreting this evidence:
- ▸Small sample size (n=66 in Intention to Treat sample)
- ▸Short four-week time frame
- ▸Control group's sleep diary completion may have had therapeutic effects, confounding results
Frequently Asked Questions
Did the online counselling improve sleep efficiency in shift workers?▼
Both the counselling and control groups showed significant improvements in sleep efficiency, but the counselling was not significantly better than just completing sleep diaries.
What was the primary outcome measured in this study?▼
The primary outcome was sleep efficiency, measured via sleep diaries.
Who were the participants in this trial?▼
The participants were German shift workers from various industries, recruited through an anonymous online platform.
Why might the control group have improved?▼
The control group completed weekly sleep diaries, which may have had a therapeutic effect by increasing self-monitoring and awareness of sleep patterns.
References
- 1.Retzer L, Graessel E, Feil M, Lehmann R, Stemmler M, Richter K. “Efficacy of an anonymous, preventive, personalized online counselling to improve shift workers' sleep quality: a randomized controlled trial..” Scientific reports, 2026. PMID: 42527422 DOI: 10.1038/s41598-026-64210-7